Marilyn Bushnell and Associates

Front porch of the Inn at Tabbs Creek - with buyers and sellers

Case Study: How The Inn at Tabbs Creek Found Its Next Owners

Congratulations to Ridge and Sherry Crewss, who at the end of December 2024 became the new stewards of The Inn at Tabbs Creek in Port Haywood, Virginia. They took over from Greg and Lori Dusenberry, who had owned and operated the waterfront B&B since 2008. The sale took 438 days from listing to closing. Two challenges shaped it: a building that looked worse than it was, and financials that undersold the business.

Pricing an inn as a business and as a home

Before listing, we did a full Marketability Assessment & Valuation (MA&V) of the inn as an operating business. The sellers’ local real estate agent separately valued the underlying property as a residential estate. The two numbers came out close to each other, so we used our dual-listing approach. The local agent marketed the property to residential buyers through the MLS, and we marketed it nationally as an operating inn. Smaller and underperforming inns often benefit from this setup. It reaches local and national buyers at once, and it gives sellers a local contact throughout the process.

Both sides of the table

We supported both sides of this sale. While we worked with the sellers, we were also helping Ridge and Sherry search for their next hospitality business. After looking at several other properties, they chose Tabbs Creek.

A building worth saving

The biggest concern was structural damage to the owners’ quarters and one guest suite. At first glance, buyers could read that section as a teardown. Ridge and Sherry investigated and found it wasn’t. With structural repairs, the building could be saved, and they went on to renovate it completely.

Numbers that undersold the inn

The financials were weaker than the property deserved. The website was dated, and the owners had put limited effort into growing the business in their later years. The sellers updated the website during the listing period. Even so, a buyer had to be able to see what the inn could earn, not just what it was earning. That’s part of why the business buyer pool for this property was narrower.

The handover

The transition went smoothly. Both parties wanted it to work and helped each other through every step it required.

What sellers can take from this

Two lessons stand out. First, a property whose business and real estate values are close can benefit from being marketed both ways. Second, investing in a website and in visible business growth before listing makes the business case easier for buyers to see. If you’re thinking about selling, we’d be glad to talk through your options.

Updated October 2026 with the full story of the sale.

author avatar
Client Admin

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Call for Assistance
Contact Business Icon

Contact

Inns button Icon

Inns

Presentation Icon

Learn

FAQs
close X
Find My RoomBook Now