Marilyn Bushnell and Associates

New owners Liz and Jeremy Lehrkamp in front of the Colette's Bed & Breakfast sign in Port Angeles, Washington

Case Study: An Off-Market Search That Led to Colette’s

Please join us in congratulating Liz and Jeremy Lehrkamp, the new owners of Colette’s Bed & Breakfast in Port Angeles, Washington. Colette’s is a five-suite inn on about 10 oceanfront acres along the Strait of Juan de Fuca, with the Olympic Mountains behind it. It is a Select Registry inn and has earned a AAA Four Diamond rating. The purchase closed on October 8, 2026.

Buyers who did their homework

Liz and Jeremy started their search in the spring of 2024, and they came prepared. Before they looked seriously at any inn, they put real time into learning how the business works. They also built a structured way to research and compare properties. At its center was a list of must-haves and must-not-haves that was specific but flexible enough to bend for the right inn.

Their search covered two very different regions, the Pacific Northwest and the mountains of North Carolina and Virginia, and more than 100 properties. Their professional backgrounds showed in that approach: Liz’s in federal law enforcement and Jeremy’s as an IT consultant. Both careers reward careful investigation and good systems.

Finding inns that weren’t for sale

Many good inns are never publicly listed. Owners may not have decided to sell, or they may want to keep a possible sale confidential. For Liz and Jeremy, we contacted the owners of Colette’s and several other properties directly to find out whether they would consider selling. That gave our clients access to inns no other buyer was seeing.

Colette’s was one of those inns. It was never publicly listed for sale. The sellers were represented by a local real estate agent, and we worked solely on the buyers’ side as their buyer consultants.

What buyers can take from this

Three lessons stand out:

  1. Preparation shortens the path. Buyers who understand the business before they start looking can judge opportunities faster and negotiate with more confidence.
  2. A clear method keeps a big search manageable. A list of must-haves and must-not-haves lets you compare more than 100 very different properties, in different regions, on the same terms. Building in some flexibility keeps you from ruling out the right inn too early.
  3. The listings are only part of the market. Some of the best opportunities come from conversations with owners who haven’t put their inns on the market.

If you’re beginning your own search, let’s talk about how we can help. If you’re earlier in the process, our free one-on-one aspiring innkeeper conversation is a good place to start.

author avatar
Client Admin

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Call for Assistance
Contact Business Icon

Contact

Inns button Icon

Inns

Presentation Icon

Learn

FAQs
close X
Find My RoomBook Now